| Gardner, Earl (Red) | 2025 | Golf Coach 18 years, Boys & Girls Basketball Coach 23 years |
| Brown, Rebecca '90 | 2025 | Soccer, Girls Basketball, Softball |
| Karl, Ellerie '00 | 2025 | Soccer, Girls Basketball |
| Bonner, Jeff '04 | 2025 | Football, Boys Basketball |
| Stone, Paul | 2025 | Football Coach 1997–2010, Girls Basketball 1997–2001, Boys Basketball 2002–2023 & 2025–present, Girls Golf |
| 2010–2013 Boys Golf Teams | 2025 | Boys Golf |
| Emde, Carl (Fritz) '53 | 2024 | Football, Boys Basketball, Baseball |
| Requarth, Jeff '71 | 2024 | Boys Basketball |
| Tully, Shannon '91 | 2024 | Tennis |
| Badger, Emily '98 | 2024 | Soccer, Softball |
| Wald, Cara '07 | 2024 | Tennis, Girls Basketball |
| 1979–80 Girls Basketball Team | 2024 | Girls Basketball |
| Storms, John (Jack) '36 | 2023 | Football, Boys Basketball, Baseball, Golf |
| Roberts, Charlie '84 | 2023 | Soccer, Baseball |
| Gregory, Laura '98 | 2023 | Soccer, Girls Basketball, Softball |
| Gregory, Janie '98 | 2023 | Soccer, Girls Basketball, Softball |
| Hix, Peter '10 | 2023 | Cross Country, Track & Field |
| 1974 & 1975 Field Hockey Teams | 2023 | Field Hockey |
| Worthington, Robert (Wid) '38 | 2022 | Football, Boys Basketball, Track, Golf |
| Nichols O'Hara, Barbara '59 | 2022 | Field Hockey, Girls Basketball, Tennis |
| Hochwalt-Buerschen, Mary '77 | 2022 | Tennis |
| May Jr, Ken '93 | 2022 | Boys Basketball |
| Thorton-Cafarella, Kelsey '02 | 2022 | Soccer, Girls Basketball |
| 2009 Boys Golf Team | 2022 | Boys Golf |
| Creager, Tom '49 | 2021 | Football, Tennis |
| Lohmeyer, Jen | 2021 | Golf Coach 2005–2013, 2017–2020 |
| Macllwaine-Bendersky, Wendy '85 | 2021 | Soccer, Girls Basketball, Track |
| Brundige, Bob '62 | 2021 | Football, Boys Basketball, Tennis, Track |
| Reston, Jim '27 | 2021 | Golf |
| 1972 Wrestling Team | 2021 | Wrestling |
| Wenzke, Jerry '59 | 2020 | Football, Boys Basketball, Track |
| Stiver, Mark | 2020 | Track & Field Coach 1995–Present |
| Corrado, Rob '99 | 2020 | Boys Basketball, Baseball |
| Hardy, Chris '08 | 2020 | Football, Boys Basketball, Baseball |
| Haviland, Kelsey '08 | 2020 | Tennis |
| 1979 Football Team | 2020 | Football |
| Wysocki, Ed | 2019 | Football Coach 1954–1964 |
| Wilson, Ann '73 | 2019 | Field Hockey, Volleyball, Girls Basketball, Tennis |
| Hochwalt, John '99 | 2019 | Soccer, Wrestling |
| Woessner, Geri '00 | 2019 | Soccer, Girls Basketball, Track |
| Hughes, Mark | 2019 | Athletic Director 1995–2013 |
| 2005 Girls Tennis Team | 2019 | Girls Tennis |
| Kimmel Oliver, Marianna '40 | 2018 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Tennis, Badminton |
| Loucks, Craig '68 | 2018 | Baseball, Basketball, Golf |
| Jervis, Tom '74 | 2018 | Multiple Sports |
| Pine, Rob '86 | 2018 | Multiple Sports |
| Henninger, Leah '06 | 2018 | Swimming |
| 1998 Softball Team | 2018 | Softball |
| Hughes, D.R., Jr. (Turk) '44 | 2017 | Football, Baseball, Basketball |
| Chappell, Steve '62 | 2017 | Football, Basketball, Baseball |
| 1978 Baseball Team | 2017 | Baseball |
| Walters, Tom '79 | 2017 | Golf |
| Parrish, Lisa '90 | 2017 | Track, Soccer |
| Folkerth, Gene '50 | 2017 | Football, Golf |
| Jandel, Emma '06 | 2016 | Golf, Girls Basketball |
| Boren, Betty Lee '41 | 2016 | Field Hockey, Tennis, Softball, Basketball |
| 1953 Football Team | 2016 | Football |
| Maher Lawson, Mary '70 | 2016 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Volleyball, Tennis, Cheerleading |
| Magill, Joe '78 | 2016 | Cross Country, Track, Football Kicker |
| Lewis, Nick '05 | 2016 | Football, Basketball, Baseball |
| Carr, Howard | 2015 | Track & Cross Country Coach |
| Johnson, Dick '49 | 2015 | Multiple Sports |
| Wise, Jamie '72 | 2015 | Field Hockey, Volleyball, Basketball, Golf |
| Bair, Richard '80 | 2015 | Baseball, Football |
| 1985 Football Team | 2015 | Football |
| Schauer, Betsy '94 | 2015 | Cross Country, Track, Basketball |
| Flotron, Leo '79 | 2014 | Basketball |
| 1935 Football Team | 2014 | Football |
| Shaffer, Jane '69 | 2014 | Girls Basketball, Tennis, Volleyball, Softball, Field Hockey |
| Easton, Jon '86 | 2014 | Soccer |
| Whalen, Lesley '99 | 2014 | Tennis, Track |
| Whalen, Christy '01 | 2014 | Tennis, Track |
| Epstein, Betty '53 | 2013 | Multiple Sports |
| Stefan, Chris '41 | 2013 | Football, Basketball, Track, Baseball |
| 1971 Basketball Team | 2013 | Boys Basketball |
| Wells, Mark '72 | 2013 | Football, Baseball, Basketball |
| Nagel, Mark ' 80 | 2013 | Football, Baseball, Basketball |
| McElligott, Charlie '96 | 2013 | Track, Football |
| Hollinger (McCloud), Virginia '36 | 2012 | Tennis |
| Priest Fickert, Lissa '71 | 2012 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Softball, Field Hockey Coach |
| Hines, Dan '86 | 2012 | Football, Basketball |
| Seim, Paul '92 | 2012 | Wrestling, Football, Track |
| 1997 Baseball Team | 2012 | Baseball |
| Warring, Nicholas '57 | 2012 | Football, Basketball, Tennis, Track |
| Seidl, Chip (Coach) | 2011 | Wrestling & Football Coach |
| 1941–1947 Field Hockey Teams | 2011 | Field Hockey |
| Lohmeyer, Steve '01 | 2011 | Golf |
| Mills, Dwight "Dusty" '35 | 2011 | Football, Basketball, Baseball, Track, Golf |
| MacKay, Bonnie '51 | 2011 | Field Hockey, Basketball, Tennis, Badminton, Softball |
| Boose, Russell '89 | 2011 | Soccer |
| Servis, Bob '33 | 2010 | Basketball, Baseball, Golf |
| Creager, Mike '61 | 2010 | Football, Track/Cross Country |
| Rasor, Dan '67 | 2010 | Coach & Trainer |
| 1985 Golf Team | 2010 | Golf |
| Roedersheimer, Carrie '87 | 2010 | Cross Country, Track |
| Motto, Nicole '00 | 2010 | Basketball, Tennis |
| Sales, Howard (Coach) | 2009 | Football & Track Coach |
| Neal, George '31 | 2009 | Football, Basketball, Track |
| Blose, Howard '40 | 2009 | Football, Track, Basketball |
| 1942 Football Team | 2009 | Football |
| Coughlin, Tim '64 | 2009 | Football, Basketball, Track |
| Deddens, Katy '93 | 2009 | Track, Field Hockey, Swimming |
| Cook, Edward Tiffin | 2008 | Football & Track Coach |
| Hayner, Bess | 2008 | Coach |
| Hummon, Mack | 2008 | Boys Tennis & Football Coach |
| MacKay, Barry '53 | 2008 | Tennis, Basketball |
| Burton, Katie '81 | 2008 | Track |
| 1929 Track Team | 2008 | Track & Field |
| Sauer, John '43 | 2008 | Football, Basketball, Track |
| Pierce, Joe "Buzz" '64 | 2008 | Tennis, Basketball |
| Beardmore, Roger Oliver (Dr.) '69 | 2008 | Football, Track |
| Howell, Dan '73 | 2008 | Wrestling |
| Tuzzi, Marisa '95 | 2008 | Track |
