College Commitments
| Name | Sport | Graduation Year | College |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Keyes | Wrestling | 2026 | Ohio Northern University |
| Riley Morrissey | Soccer | 2026 | Baldwin Wallace University |
| Lillian Rodriguez | Rowing | 2026 | Marietta College |
| Cara Ippisch | Field Hockey | 2026 | Washington & Jefferson College |
| Finn McCarty | Football | 2026 | Carnegie Mellon University |
| Kate Donnelly | Cross Country and Track | 2026 | DePauw University |
| Caroline Roelle | Girls Basketball | 2026 | Grove City College |
| Josh Tribble | Baseball | 2026 | Tiffin University |
| Braden Devine | Baseball | 2026 | St. Norbert College |
| Matilda Prizler | Swimming | 2026 | New York University |
| Addie Kash | Track & Field (Pole Vault) | 2026 | Oregon State |
| Evie Connor | Volleyball | 2026 | Ohio Dominican |
| William Usechak | Baseball | 2025 | Hiram |
| Luke Rubin | Basketball | 2025 | Denison |
| Truman Brun | Swimming | 2025 | Xavier |
| Elizabeth Erwin | Cross Country | 2025 | Taylor |
| Adriana Eliopulos | Field Hockey | 2025 | Wellesley |
| Izzie Kline | Field Hockey | 2025 | Wooster |
| Josie Russell | Soccer | 2025 | Denison |
| Paige Simon | Swimming | 2025 | Ithaca |
| Lewis Erwin | Baseball | 2024 | Mt. Vernon Nazarene |
| Nathan Lloyd | Baseball | 2024 | Denison |
| Aidan Jacomet | Basketball | 2024 | Franciscan |
| Colin MacDonald | Soccer | 2024 | Denison |
| Tristan Prizler | Swimming | 2024 | Northwestern |
| Arick Baldwin | Tennis | 2024 | Allegheny |
| Noah Boyce | Tennis | 2024 | Ohio Northern |
| Sam Garay | Tennis | 2024 | Wittenberg |
| Steve Lauterbach | Football | 2024 | Wittenberg |
| JJ Wilson | Football | 2024 | Wittenberg |
| Floralysse Biteau | Cross Country | 2024 | Denison |
| Lilia Blumer | Field Hockey | 2024 | Meredith |
| Kate Makkas | Soccer | 2024 | Youngstown St |
| Lily Epley | Swimming | 2024 | Bellarmine |
| Emma Neff | Basketball | 2023 | Cedarville |
| Riley Cahill | Baseball | 2023 | Dayton |
| Carson Baumgardner | Wrestling | 2023 | Campbellsville |
| Nate Clark | Lacrosse | 2023 | Grove City |
| Jason Purks | Soccer | 2023 | Northern Kentucky U |
| Josh Rosenberg | Baseball | 2023 | Knox |
| Max Parker | Lacrosse | 2023 | Roanoke College |
| Emma Almoney | Soccer | 2023 | Trinity |
| Will Maxwell | Basketball | 2023 | Dayton |
| Jack Epley | Lacrosse | 2022 | Florida Southern |
| Sam Campbell | Swimming | 2022 | Ohio State |
| Cade Zonin | Football | 2022 | Rose Hulman |
| Grace Hartman | Cross Country & Track | 2022 | North Carolina State |
| Norah Miller | Rowing | 2022 | MIT |
| Emma LLoyd | Soccer | 2022 | Florida Southern |
| Sadie Knostman | Track | 2022 | Wittenberg |
| Gracie Taylor | Softball | 2022 | Methodist U |
| Hannah Moulton | Cross Country | 2021 | Dayton |
| Paige Reymann | Rowing | 2021 | Tennessee |
| Fia McCarthy | Swimming | 2021 | Boston U |
| Brandon Cahill | Baseball | 2021 | Walsh |
| Darin Rubin | Basketball | 2020 | Denison |
| Rylan Quigley | Golf | 2020 | Otterbein U |
| Jonathan Duff | Football | 2020 | Eastern Kentucky U |
| Kylie Foos | Basketball | 2020 | Wittenberg |
| Landon Sandoval | Baseball | 2019 | Bluffton U |
| Sam Lahmon | Golf | 2019 | Otterbein U |
| Garrett Hart | Lacrosse | 2019 | Furman U |
| Sam Auditore | Swimming | 2019 | Washington U |
| Jake Sargent | Football | 2019 | Dayton |
| Lauren Hapgood | Basketball | 2019 | SW Oklahoma St. U |
| Hannah Grushon | Field Hockey | 2019 | Earlham |
| Katie King | Field Hockey | 2019 | Southern New Hampshire |
| Torrie Studebaker | Field Hockey | 2019 | Earlham |
| Agatha Shafer | Rowing | 2019 | Naval Academy |
| Dylan Caplette | Football | 2018 | Ohio Wesleyan U |
| Brendan Talarcyzk | Football | 2018 | Brown U |
| Sabella All | Swimming | 2018 | Arizona St |
| Emily Worley | Track | 2018 | University of Toledo |
| Hannah Grupe | Volleyball | 2018 | MIT |
| Connor Quigley | Golf | 2017 | Dayton |
| Emmy Cobb | Golf | 2017 | Dayton |
| Emilee Koenig | Rowing | 2017 | Michigan St |
| Liam Halpin | Swimming | 2017 | Buffalo |
| Kathleen Mulligan | Swimming | 2017 | Florida Atlantic |
| Lucas Layman | Baseball | 2016 | Rio Grande |
| Mary Kate Vaughn | Cross Country | 2016 | Boston College |
| Michael Hoecht | Football | 2016 | Brown |
| Michelle Shampton | Field Hockey | 2015 | Ball State U |
| Peanut Johnson | Field Hockey | 2012 | Ohio State |